The Rundown:
The old saying goes, “fortune favors the bold'', and the draft selection of Patrick Baldwin Jr. certainly puts that proverb to the test. He made one of the boldest decisions a 5 star high school prospect has ever made in going to the University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee, to be coached by his father. This makes scouting him exponentially more difficult, but a good type of difficult. This is a case study on competition and usage that is painful but necessary. So, into the meat of it.
Offensively is where the broad majority of his appeal lies. At 6’10, his scoring package is ridiculously versatile, with just about every shot in his disposal. Easily one of the best shooting prospects in the class, he has legitimate movement shooting ability, be it off of screens, pin downs, or trailing in transition. He can shoot off the dribble or off the catch, off a standstill or with fades and leans (there are some bad misses to start the year but until it gets past the range of small sample sizes we’re gonna let it slide). Whenever you think that you are gonna lower your expectations about PBJ, he does a 3 dribble move combo to hit a mid range fade over the outstretched arms of a defender and you are back on the bandwagon. Outside of scoring, there is less going for him, but as a 6’10 dominant scorer the rest tends to not matter if he is at least average at the ancillary skills (think Michael Porter Jr.). However, it would take a fair bit of improvement to get to those average skills.
Defense should be easier, as he isn’t an idiot, has good lateral quickness and fluidity, all on top of a 6’10 frame with a clear plus wingspan. The main problem plaguing him at the moment is effort based. He tends to fall asleep on defense, especially offball, especially when he isn’t the focal point of the offense on the other side. His role in the NBA most likely isn't focal point so this problem needs to be shored up. He has the size and wherewithal to be an impactful defender, but the desire has to be there. On offense, playmaking is a genuine worry. There will always be some offball gravity, giving him prebaked playmaking, but onball, the reads aren’t the quickest or the most advanced. This problem is amplified by him playing at Wisconsin-Milwaukee, as his teammates aren’t always the most well suited to put the ball in the basket. However, Baldin will be given a long leash to fix these errors, because players that tall who can shoot that well aren’t exactly a dime a dozen. The real question is whether he has the motor or cares enough to fix these problems.
Exceptional shooting prospect from everywhere on the floor, off the catch or dribble, with an insanely versatile scoring package. His defensive effort is sometimes lacking, and the reads he makes aren’t advanced, but this type of shooting is one in a million.
Michael Porter Jr with a bit more separation equity, Klay with - defense, and as a worse outcome, Andrea Bargnani